Check the hardware combination
Apple’s AirPods guide describes the feature for Apple TV 4K and compatible Apple wireless headphones. Its Beats guide likewise names Apple TV 4K. Do not infer support from the presence of Bluetooth alone or from an older Apple TV being able to connect one ordinary headset.
For a planned two-person session, note both headphone models and identify the Apple TV hardware. If one pair belongs to a guest, agree who will carry out the pairing prompts. Keep the television at a modest volume while preparing, particularly if another person nearby is resting.
Add the second listener deliberately
Start with the first compatible pair connected. Open Control Center using the TV button, move to the headphone area and choose Share Audio. Follow the prompts to connect the second pair. The exact icon can reflect the headphones already in use.
Use a familiar short passage to ask each viewer whether they hear the intended programme. Check the actual listening result for each pair instead of judging only by a successful pairing message. If only one person hears sound, identify which pair and where in the joining sequence the second pair failed before repeating the whole procedure.
